Magnons in Computing

Silicon Scoop · April 1, 2025

The Rise of Magnons in Computing In the quest for more efficient and faster computing, magnon computing emerges as a promising frontier. Magnons, quasiparticles representing collective spin excitations in magnetic materials, are being explored as alternatives to electrons, which have powered computing for decades. This survey note delves into what magnons are, their properties, and […]

With Craig Major and Jon Irwin

Open audio in your browser

Home » Magnons in Computing

Estimated reading time: 8 minutes

The Rise of Magnons in Computing

In the quest for more efficient and faster computing, magnon computing emerges as a promising frontier. Magnons, quasiparticles representing collective spin excitations in magnetic materials, are being explored as alternatives to electrons, which have powered computing for decades. This survey note delves into what magnons are, their properties, and their potential to revolutionize computing, addressing the user’s query on whether they could be the next electron.

Defining Magnons: The Basics

Magnons are not fundamental particles but quasiparticles, akin to phonons in crystals or photons in light. They are the quanta of spin waves, where electron spins in a magnetic material oscillate collectively. In ferromagnets, at absolute zero, spins align perfectly, but as temperature rises, deviations create these waves, each a magnon. Key properties include:

Energy and Momentum: Each magnon carries specific energy and lattice momentum, determined by the material.
Boson Behavior: They follow Bose-Einstein statistics, allowing multiple occupancy in quantum states.
Types: Include ferromagnetic, antiferromagnetic, and paramagnons, depending on the material’s magnetic order.

Detection methods like inelastic neutron scattering, Brillouin light scattering, and ferromagnetic resonance help study them, revealing their behavior under various conditions.

Magnons in Computing: How They Work

In computing, magnons encode information via their wave properties—amplitude, phase, and frequency. They propagate through magnetic materials, controlled by geometry or fields, enabling waveguides for data transmission. Logic operations leverage interference, with AND gates from constructive interference and NOT gates from phase shifts. Memory storage uses magnon presence or orientation for binary states, offering no-charge transport for lower energy use and wave-based computing for parallel processing.

Advantages Over Electron-Based Systems

Magnon computing shines in energy efficiency, avoiding Joule heating from electron movement. They can match or exceed electron speeds, support parallel processing via interference, and scale to nanoscale for compact devices. Novel paradigms, like spin wave logic, and compatibility with magnetic technologies like MRAM, enhance their appeal for high-performance computing.

Current Research Landscape

Research is active, with prototypes like logic gates and memory units developed, using materials like yttrium iron garnet (YIG) for long-lived spin waves. Integration with CMOS technology is underway, and quantum aspects, such as magnons as qubits, are explored. Simulations guide design, but challenges remain in control and noise management.

Challenges and Limitations

Key hurdles include precise magnon control, signal-to-noise ratios affected by thermal noise, scalability to large circuits, and compatibility with electronics. A deeper fundamental understanding is needed, especially in complex structures, to unlock full potential.

How Altermagnetism Fits into Magnon-Based Computing

Altermagnetism is a newly discovered type of magnetism that combines properties of both ferromagnetism and antiferromagnetism. It fits into the equation of magnon-based computing as a potentially transformative material class that could enhance the efficiency, scalability, and performance of future computing technologies. Below, we’ll explore what altermagnetism is, why it matters for magnon-based computing, and its potential impact.

What is Altermagnetism?

Altermagnetism is a unique type of magnetism with the following key characteristics:

Zero net magnetization: Like antiferromagnets, altermagnets do not produce a net magnetic field, which reduces interference with nearby components.
Strong spin polarization: Unlike antiferromagnets, altermagnets exhibit alternating spin polarization, similar to ferromagnets, which is crucial for manipulating magnons (quasiparticles that carry spin information).

This combination makes altermagnets particularly suited for magnon-based computing, where information is processed using magnons rather than electrons.

Why Altermagnetism Matters for Magnon-Based Computing

Magnon-based computing aims to use magnons to process and store data without the energy loss associated with electron flows, which generate heat. However, traditional magnetic materials like ferromagnets and antiferromagnets have limitations:

Ferromagnets:
- Produce a net magnetic field, which can interfere with nearby components.
- This interference limits how densely devices can be packed, posing challenges for scalability.
Antiferromagnets:
- Have no net magnetic field, making them suitable for dense packing.
- However, they lack the spin-splitting behavior needed for certain magnon manipulations.

Altermagnets address these limitations:

No net magnetic field: This allows for tighter packing of components without interference, which is crucial for scaling down devices.
Spin-splitting behavior: Altermagnets have alternating spin polarization, meaning they can still manipulate magnons effectively, similar to ferromagnets.

In essence, altermagnets offer the control and efficiency needed for magnon-based computing without the drawbacks of traditional magnetic materials.

Potential Impact on Computing

If altermagnets can be successfully integrated into magnon-based systems, they could have significant impacts:

Increased speed: Altermagnets could enable faster data processing, potentially in the terahertz range, compared to current gigahertz speeds.
Improved energy efficiency: By reducing heat generation and energy loss, altermagnets could make computing more sustainable.
Enhanced scalability: Their lack of a net magnetic field means components can be packed more densely, leading to smaller, more powerful devices.

These advantages could lead to breakthroughs in various applications, including faster memory devices and potentially even quantum computing components.

Challenges and Outlook

While altermagnetism is promising, it is still in its early stages. Researchers are working to address several challenges:

Control: Precisely controlling altermagnetic states is essential for practical applications.
Integration: Developing ways to integrate altermagnets with existing technologies is necessary for widespread adoption.
Applications: Identifying and developing practical applications, such as faster memory devices or quantum computing components, is ongoing.

Despite these challenges, altermagnetism represents an exciting frontier in computing, potentially unlocking new ways to process information faster and more efficiently.

Summary

Altermagnetism fits into the equation of magnon-based computing as a material class that combines the best of ferromagnetism and antiferromagnetism. With zero net magnetization and strong spin polarization, altermagnets could enable faster, more efficient, and scalable computing systems. While challenges remain, the potential of altermagnets to transform computing technology makes them a promising area of research and development.

Future Prospects and Applications

The future looks bright, with applications in high-performance computing, AI, IoT for low-power devices, quantum computing for qubits, and magnetic memory for denser, faster storage. Researchers aim for sub-100nm devices, potentially transforming telecommunications with magnonic filters.

Comparing Magnons and Electrons

Aspect	Electrons	Magnons
Charge	Carry electric charge	Charge-neutral
Spin	Intrinsic spin	Collective spin excitation
Mass	Have mass	Considered massless in approximations
Conduction	Move freely in conductors	Propagate as waves in magnets
Energy Efficiency	Generate heat via Joule heating	Lower energy loss, no charge transport
Speed	High in conductors	Comparable or faster in magnets

This comparison highlights magnons’ edge in energy and scalability, though electrons dominate current systems due to established infrastructure.

Historical Context

Magnon research began with Felix Bloch in 1930, explaining magnetization reduction. Theory advanced with Holstein and Primakoff in 1940, using second quantization, and experimental detection came in 1957 via Brockhouse’s neutron scattering. Magnonics, focusing on spin wave control, is a recent subfield, driving computing innovations.

Analogies for Better Understanding

Magnons are like sound waves in air—disturbances propagating information. They’re also like water ripples in a pond, spreading from an impact, or light, with wave-particle duality. These analogies make their wave-based computing role clearer, akin to sound carrying music or light transmitting data.

Conclusion

Magnon computing could indeed be the next electron, offering energy efficiency, speed, and new paradigms. While challenges persist, ongoing research suggests a transformative future, especially in AI, IoT, and quantum realms. This comprehensive analysis positions magnons as a key player in computing’s evolution.

Key Citations

Additional Links
• Silicon Scoop Podcast – Stay Informed, Stay Ahead!
• Futuretech Podcast – Explore more episodes and stay updated with the latest in technology and innovation.
• Startup Talk Podcast – https://torontostarts.com/startup-talk-toronto-startup-podcast/
• Who Are These Startups Podcast
• Startup Investor Drinks – Join the community and connect with fellow startup enthusiasts and investors.
• TorontoStarts Startup and Entrepreneur Community – Become a part of Toronto’s thriving startup ecosystem.
• Workhaus – Discover flexible workspace solutions for your business needs.
• Work with The Startup Coach – Get expert guidance and mentorship for your startup journey.
• Reach out to Jon Irwin on LinkedIn – Connect with our co-host and technology expert.

Ontario Startup Ecosystem Links

• Ontario’s Startup Ecosystem
• Startup Funding in Ontario
• Angel Investors in Ontario
• Ontario Incubators and Accelerators
• Venture Capital in Ontario: Top Firms, Sectors, and Funding Strategies
• Government Grants for Ontario Startups
• Ontario’s Startup Success Stories
• Ontario Centre of Innovation (OCI)
• Bank Loans and Financing for Startups in Ontario
• Research and Development Tax Credits in Ontario
• Government Loans and Financing for Startups in Ontario
• Equity Crowdfunding for Ontario Startups
• Toronto Entrepreneurs Resources
• Toronto’s Food and Beverage Entrepreneurs: Trends, Challenges, and Success Stories
• SEO Strategies for Toronto Entrepreneurs: Enhance Your Online Visibility
• Social Impact for Toronto Entrepreneurs: Starting and Running a Socially Responsible Business
• Toronto Arts and Media Entrepreneurs: Inspiring Profiles and Insights for Creative Success
• Exploring Toronto Green Tech Entrepreneurs: Innovators and Leaders in Sustainability
• Building a Team for Toronto Entrepreneurs: Strategies for Success
• A Guide for Toronto Food and Beverage Entrepreneurs
• Toronto Fashion and Retail Entrepreneurs: Trends, Opportunities, and Success Stories

Episode transcript

Read the full transcript

Jon: so goodbye electrons. hello, magnons. charged particles are a thing of the past and we're moving forward with magnons in computers, electronics because they're faster, better, less noise. what's going on here, john?

Craig: yeah. i wasn't able to do a deep dive into this, so i apologize if i make mistakes or anything like this, but this is really cool from earth dot com, the article i found. researchers at university of california, they made apparently a groundbreaking discovery that could revolutionize computing technology. and i don't think this relates to quantum, but it could. but they found a way to use magnons, which are waves of electron spin to transmit information within the computer chip itself. so this could lead to computers that are significantly faster and more efficient than current electron based systems. so magnons, unlike electrons, this is weird, don't carry an electric charge, which means they can move through materials without generating heat or experiencing resistance, which could potentially solve one of the major limitations of current computing technology. so in this article, they said that the team demonstrated that magnons can be used to carry binary information over relatively long distances within a chip itself. and so guys, just so you know, we're talking about like two nanometers, three nanometers, four nanometers chips, but that is a long distance to carry binary information. but this could open up possibilities for new computer architecture. the cool thing about this discovery is, and craig, you and i have talked about moore's law. moore's law predicts the slowing of progress in traditional electronic computing. so this is outside of magnons, but magnon based computing could overcome those limitations, which is really exciting.

Jon: i'm excited about this. and i'm excited about this in combination with what we've talked about a couple of weeks ago with ultra magnetism, which is the third type of magnetism where magnon based computing aims to use magnons to process and store data without energy loss associated with electron flows, which generate heat. however, traditional magnetic materials like ferromagnetics and antiferromagnetics have limitations. ferromagnetics produce a net magnetic field, which can interfere with nearby components. this interference limits how densely devices can be packed. anti ferromagnetics, they have no net magnetic field making them suitable for dense packing. however, they lack the spin splitting behavior needed for certain magnon manipulations. so altern magnetics come in. what we talked about the third type of no magnetic field. this allows for tighter packing of components without interference, which is crucial for scaling devices and alternating spin polarization, meaning they can still manipulate magnons effectively leaving us effectively similar to ferromagnets. so i'm excited about these two things together to take us to the future on these things.

Craig: yeah, so i just did a quick search using perplexity about may nuns with quantum computing. they actually could help quantum computing. so they could serve as quantum information carriers. they could be used to create hybrid quantum systems. they could act as quantum transducers, and they could offer new approaches to quantum error correction outside of majorana one, which is cool. so for traditional computing, obviously you've got low power computing, faster data processing, nvm or non volatile memory, and could enable new paradigms and analog computing. so it's got a benefit to both quantum and traditional.

Jon: we talk about massive energy savings using this type of technology over massive ai data centers where we're talking about gigawatts to power these things. so be curious to see how quickly they're gonna be moving to magnons.

Craig: let's hope it's fast because i think this is good. what's this chart you have here?

Jon: i switched away, hang on.

Craig: oh, you're comparing magnons to electrons. do you want me to go through it?

Jon: yeah, go ahead.

Craig: okay, so for those of you just to kind of compare it side by side, electrons carry an electric charge, magnons carry a neutral charge or don't carry a charge at all, that's neutral. the spin of electrons are intrinsic, whereas magnons have a collective spin excitation. electrons have a mass, magnons are considered massless in approximations, and we're not going to get into infinity and approximations and all that sort of stuff, but just leave it at that guys, please. conduction, they move freely in conductors, whereas magnons propagate as waves in magnets. as far as energy efficiency, they generate heat via dual heating, whereas magnons have a lower energy loss because they have no charge to transport. and as far as speed goes, electrons are very fast in conductors, but magnons comparable or faster in magnets. so really interesting comparison there.

Jon: yeah, and electrons dominate current systems due to established infrastructure. so we're gonna have to see where this goes. and magnon research, as you mentioned, began back in nineteen thirty in nineteen forty with the second quantization and some experimentation in nineteen fifty seven. there's a lot of stuff here. this is transformative in ai, iot and the quantum rounds, as you mentioned.

Craig: yeah. so guys, just to kind of, for those of you that put it into perspective, a chip generates heat, that's because of electrons flowing in that chip. so if we can eliminate that heat, we may eliminate the need for heat sinks, we may eliminate the need for a bunch of things and be able to crank up this power and reduce power consumption, which is really interesting.

Jon: yeah, i'm just trying to see dates.

Craig: as far as when we'll see something? yeah. yeah, i couldn't find anything.

Jon: i'll take a look. all right, i'm excited about this. i'm excited about this with altar magnetism and a couple of other breakthroughs that are coming. let us know what you think. are you looking forward to magnons powering your phones and your computer devices and ai data centers, which will probably get it first, the high end computers. let us know what you think and whether you think the feature is magnons or not. and according to our timeline, it says prototypes will be developed in the next five to ten years with widespread adoption, taking place in fifteen to twenty years.

Craig: you know what's funny is i laugh when i say five to ten years because like it seems like everything is five to ten years away. we talked about that before.

Jon: yeah. and that's when we were doing batteries at one time, made that battery chart because some of them were coming out this year or next year and some of them were farther away. i just wanted to put it all because it always seems like it's five to ten years.

Craig: yeah, exactly.

More from Silicon Scoop

All episodes